e.l.f.Liquid Eyeliner, High-pigment Liquid Eyeliner With Extra-Fine Brush Tip, Easy Glide Smudge-proof Formula, Jet Black

Why did you pick this product vs others?:I don't buy any other eyeliner anymore, and I don't think I ever will again. As an alternative girl I use A LOTTT of eyeliner, and this little bottle typically lasts me about 6-8 months, which is more than I would expect for its size/price and how often I use it. It doesn't smudge or get runny, it doesn't stain, the application is precise, it's very opaque, and its viscosity remains consistent. I have no complaints about this product!P.S. (Additionally, I am brown-skinned, and it still shows up on my skin tone perfectly, so if you have darker skin, it should work fine!)

I've been wearing this eyeliner for years and it hasn't failed me yet! It's a great liquid liner with a nice, thin tip, which makes it easy to apply. It's dark and dries quickly, and lasts a very long time. There's no smudging, and the best part is it's easy to take off. You're not left with raccoon eyes. It also doesnt fade throughout the day, nor does it transfer. I love love love it!

This creates the perfect wing -- I have trouble with eyeliner in general and will sometimes go without but this is the brush is thin and glides on very smoothly. The pigment is perfect. I want to try this same item in different colors since it works so well. I prefer this over a stick or gel since you can control how thick/thin your lines are. I'm still practicing. Just be sure to let the lines dry before you open your eyes b/c it does take a few seconds to dry -- but I'm sure that's the case for most liners. I'm just a beginner so I don't know if that's typical or not. I love that two are in a pack and it'll last a while.

Good quality

Great cheap liquid eyeliner. Wait until fully dried to blink lol. It does smear a bit to eyelid crease sometimes so make sure you apply finisher or powder or something

Excellent liquid eyeliner. The brush is the perfect degree of fineness for good control. I love it.

Dries quickly:Works well, dries quickly. I recommend a setting spray, but holds on pretty strong most of the day

Overall this is a good eyeliner, last all day long. Only downside is that it stays wet for a while. If you look up it smudges on your top lid, so wait for it to dry fully before looking up